How to Make Homemade Silly Putty (2 Ingredients!)

tcl homemade silly putty 2

Today was one of those days where I sat back and thought, “Wow.  Pinterest really makes me appear to be a very creative mother.”  LOL  That is SO not the case – I’m as boring as they come.  But I just love taking simple ideas and watching Lily Bean have a blast in the process.

Today’s Task: Homemade Silly Putty

Our putty came out with a shiny, “Gak”-like consistency.  I read somewhere that if you leave your putty out, uncovered overnight it will dry out a little bit, making its texture closer to the infamous “Silly-Putty-in-the-egg” that many of us played with in our youth.

This recipe calls for TWO (that’s IT) ingredients.  I love that!

You will need:

  • white, multi purpose glue (I used Elmer’s – 1 cup)
  • liquid starch (I used Sta-Flo – 1/2 cup)
  • optional: food coloring

*You can make more/less putty than we did – just stick to a “2 parts glue, 1 part starch” combo to achieve optimal putty.

tcl how to make silly putty 1

How to make:

  • Pour glue into a bowl.  I used 1 cup of glue.

tcl how to make silly putty 2

  • Add liquid starch and (if desired) food coloring to the glue.  Begin mixing ingredients together.  (I started out using a spoon to mix and eventually used my hands.

tcl how to make silly putty 3

tcl how to make silly putty 4

  • After about 5 minutes of mixing, I became skeptical as to whether or not this mess was really going to come together.  It was so stringy and snake-like!  But after even more mixing and then some kneading with my hands, we got a nice ball of putty – ready for playtime.

tcl how to make silly putty 5

tcl how to make silly putty 6

tcl how to make silly putty 8

  • And playtime it was!

tcl homemade silly putty

  • We stored our putty in a mason jar (you could easily use a ziploc bag or other airtight container).
  • Store in the refrigerator.

tcl homemade silly putty 2a